Extra-articular Augmentation in ACL Reconstruction — When Is It Indicated?

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is the mainstay of surgical treatment for instability caused by an ACL tear. In selected patients, the surgeon may add an extra-articular augmentation in ACL Reconstruction to improve rotational control and reduce the risk of graft rupture. Two options are anterolateral ligament reconstruction and lateral extra-articular tenodesis using the mini-Lemaire technique, which we will discuss in this article.

Why is extra-articular augmentation important in ACL reconstruction?
The ACL helps limit forward movement of the tibia relative to the femur and contributes to rotational control of the knee. In this second role, it works alongside structures on the outer side of the knee, including the anterolateral capsule, the anterolateral ligament, and the iliotibial band.
When this control is impaired, the knee may give way during movements such as a sudden change of direction. During the physical examination, the orthopedic surgeon assesses this type of instability using the pivot shift test. A high-grade result indicates pronounced rotational instability and supports the decision to add a lateral procedure to ACL reconstruction. The goal is to limit excessive internal rotation of the tibia and help protect the ACL graft.
When may extra-articular augmentation be indicated?
The decision takes into account the physical examination findings, the type of ACL graft, the surgical history, and the activities the patient intends to resume. The main situations include the following.
Young, active patients, particularly those aged 25 or younger, receiving a hamstring tendon graft and participating in sports involving pivoting and changes of direction, such as soccer, basketball, and handball.
Marked rotational instability on physical examination, identified through the pivot shift test.
Revision ACL reconstruction. Following the failure of a previous reconstruction, lateral augmentation may be included in the new surgical plan. The assessment also considers the position of the previous bone tunnels, the condition of the menisci, and factors such as limb alignment and posterior tibial slope.
Knee hyperextension and generalized ligamentous laxity. These findings help determine individual risk, particularly in young patients who wish to return to sports involving changes of direction.
Other risk factors. Chronic ACL deficiency, skeletal immaturity, and a return to pivoting sports are also considered. In children and adolescents with open growth plates, the choice of technique and fixation planning must account for these structures.

Anterolateral ligament reconstruction
The anterolateral ligament (ALL) is part of the group of structures that help limit internal rotation of the tibia. Reconstruction aims to reproduce the course of the ligament between the region of the lateral femoral epicondyle and the anterolateral tibia, between Gerdy’s tubercle and the fibular head.

One option is to use a gracilis tendon graft, one of the hamstring tendons. The graft passes beneath the iliotibial band and is secured near the ligament’s attachment sites. Depending on the technique, the reconstruction may use independent fixation or share the femoral tunnel with the ACL graft. Fixation placement and graft tension influence both rotational control and the preservation of knee motion.
Lateral extra-articular tenodesis using the mini-Lemaire technique
In the mini-Lemaire technique, the surgeon uses a short strip of the iliotibial band, the fibrous tissue that runs along the outer side of the thigh. The strip retains its natural attachment to the tibia at Gerdy’s tubercle. Its free end passes beneath the lateral collateral ligament and is secured to the femur, usually at a point proximal and posterior to the lateral epicondyle.

This course allows the strip to act as a restraint against excessive internal rotation of the tibia. Using the iliotibial band avoids the need to harvest another tendon for the lateral procedure. The fixation position and strip tension must be planned to control instability while preserving knee motion.
How do the two techniques compare?
Anterolateral ligament reconstruction | Mini-Lemaire | |
Tissue used | A tendon graft, such as the gracilis tendon | A strip of the iliotibial band |
Tibial attachment | Near the ALL attachment, between Gerdy’s tubercle and the fibular head | Preserves the strip’s natural attachment at Gerdy’s tubercle |
How it works | Reproduces the course of the anterolateral ligament | Uses a course beneath the lateral collateral ligament to limit excessive internal rotation |
Other lateral tenodesis procedures include the MacIntosh and Ellison techniques, which use different graft paths or fixation points. The choice depends on knee anatomy, available grafts, previous surgery, and the potential for interference between fixation sites.
How does it affect recovery?
The additional lateral approach may cause more pain during the first few weeks or months. In the STABILITY study, patients who underwent tenodesis experienced more pain early in recovery and underwent more procedures to remove fixation hardware. At two years, sports activity levels were similar between the groups. Return to sport continues to depend on the recovery of strength and movement control, along with functional assessment and consideration of any associated meniscal repairs.

For patients undergoing ACL reconstruction, the characteristics of the knee and the demands of their sport may justify lateral extra-articular augmentation. The degree of instability on examination, the planned graft, and the history of previous injuries also help determine whether to add the procedure and which technique best suits the surgical plan.
References
Sonnery-Cottet B et al. Consenso internacional sobre indicações para procedimentos extra-articulares laterais. Arthroscopy, 2025. PubMed
Getgood AMJ et al. Resultados de dois anos do ensaio randomizado STABILITY. American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2020. PubMed
Sonnery-Cottet B et al. Ensaio randomizado de reconstrução combinada do LCA e LAL com seguimento de cinco anos. The Lancet Regional Health – Europe. PubMed
Reconstrução anatômica do ligamento anterolateral com enxerto do grácil. Arthroscopy Techniques. Texto completo
Tenodese de Lemaire modificada por via minimamente invasiva. Arthroscopy Techniques. Texto completo
Eventos adversos da tenodese extra-articular lateral no ensaio STABILITY. PubMed
Abordagem da instabilidade rotatória anterolateral residual após reconstrução do LCA. Texto completo
About the author
Dr. Daniel Hidalgo is an orthopedic surgeon specializing in knee surgery and arthroscopy. He graduated from Faculdade de Medicina do ABC and completed his residency in Orthopedics and Traumatology and fellowship training in Knee Surgery at Santa Casa de São Paulo, where he also served as a clinical instructor. He further developed his training through an observership at Hôpital de la Croix-Rousse in Lyon, France.
His clinical practice includes the assessment and treatment of knee osteoarthritis, meniscal and ligament injuries, and other causes of pain and functional impairment. On this blog, he writes about orthopedics to help patients understand their diagnoses and participate in treatment decisions.
Editorial note: This article was prepared with the assistance of artificial intelligence. Dr. Daniel Hidalgo reviewed the content and is responsible for the final version.





Comments